Meeting the Mental Health Needs of Post 9/11 Veterans

Ralph IbsonBy Ralph Ibson, National Policy Director, Wounded Warrior Project

Care For Your Mind is honoring all veterans with a series of posts examining policy issues and advocacy projects around access to quality mental health care. In this first post, Ralph Ibson, National Policy Director, Wounded Warrior Project shares his views on the treatment options available to post 9/11 veterans through the VA health care system.

Efforts to provide a continuum of care to veterans

With high percentages of post-9/11 veterans now experiencing war-related mental health problems, the VA health care system faces a generational challenge. As Dr. Charles Hoge, a leading researcher in the field described it, “veterans remain reluctant to seek care, with half of those in need not utilizing mental health services. Among veterans who begin PTSD treatment with psychotherapy or medications, a high percentage drop out…with only 50% of veterans seeking care and a 40% recovery rate, current strategies will effectively reach no more than 20% of all veterans needing PTSD treatment.”

VA characterizes mental health care for veterans as one of its highest priorities.  But, pressed on many fronts, VA leaders often seek to defuse problems with the assurance that the immediate issue is “a real priority.” VA has far-ranging “priorities,” and some wonder — when everything seems a “priority” – whether anything can be.

Operating a large, integrated national health care system, VA certainly offers an extensive array of robust mental health services to veterans of all eras, with programs that span a continuum from outpatient counseling to relatively long-term specialized inpatient care for PTSD. But few facilities provide that complete continuum.

VA’s mental health system has not escaped criticism in recent years, particularly as related to treating veterans with psychic wounds incurred in overseas’ deployments.   Despite increases in VA mental health staffing over the past six years, many VA facilities have struggled to provide veterans timely access to mental health care. In some locations, VA mental health providers have described their hospitals and clinics as “overwhelmed,” and unable to provide veterans the level and frequency of care they need.  To a degree, VA’s challenges are tied to its own marketing of mental health services and outreach efforts, urging veterans to “enroll for VA health care.” The Department can also be faulted for its long insistence that “we don’t need additional mental health staff.”  For years, VA has also tolerated substantial variability in service-capacity from one VA medical center to another, and has failed to include patient-outcomes among its performance measures. And in some cases the drive to win performance-tied bonuses led administrators to game the system, masking failures to serve the patient appropriately.

Veterans supporting veterans as peer specialists

Sharply critical congressional hearings on VA mental health care led to the VA last year to acknowledge finally a need “to improve.” This acknowledgement led to decisions for new initiatives that resulted in the hiring of 1,660 additional mental health staff. Potentially as important, VA has been hiring veterans to work as peer-specialists in VA mental health programs.

Some besieged VA providers see the newly hired mental health professionals as a mere “drop in the bucket.” Despite increased pressure within VA to meet scheduling standards and providing evidence-based treatments, veterans and clinicians alike tell us that VA facilities are often unable to meet returning veterans where they are. As one combat veteran who volunteers as a peer-mentor described it, “these guys aren’t going to come in for mental health care unless things get really, really bad. And then they really need help! But the system isn’t set up to get them treatment when they need it.“ As an experienced VA mental health professional explained, “These veterans frequently come in in some kind of real crisis. They need to be seen and engaged quickly, not just added to a waiting list.” VA seeks to provide “veteran-centered mental health care;” for many post 9/11 veterans, it’s just not there yet.

Your Turn

  • Have you or a loved one sought mental health care through the VA health care system?
  • Is the VA adequately staffed to handle the mental health needs of returning veterans?
  • Have you or a loved one had the opportunity to experience the Recovery-model treatment program working with a peer specialist through the VA?
4 comments
MarkFoster1
MarkFoster1

Your 'boiler plate' response equates to "that dog don't hunt"! Fix the VA & fix this damn curser !

MarkFoster1
MarkFoster1

I completely agree with JerBear320. Being VA diagnosed with PTSD I speak first hand. In reply to "your turn" it has been my experience the VA would rather rack up the body count from suicide s than address this crisis.

VA studies have proven the immediate relief of PTSD from precribed medical marijuana.

The VA is woefully under staffed of mental heslth professionals. That being said, your "comment" box appears to intentionally exaserbate ones attempt to place the curser to correct spelling ie; health.

The VA should stop the denial of its own findings if it truely wants to put an end to all the tragic suicides. Just throwing some pill (with ttemendous side effects) is certainly NOT an answer (and you wonder why vets leave "the program" jist as I'm getting right now trying to place the curser to correct my fat fingered typos

Good day, because the damn curser has its own VA way and jumps to anywhere but to where I want to insert or correct which has my PTSD inflamed !!!

Wm.M.Foster

JerBear320
JerBear320

What is the purpose of this article? And why, oh why do we focus on only post 9/11 veterans? 

As a vet myself from the Viet Nam era, do you realize that the majority of our homeless suffer from the same effects you describe in this essay? In my opinion, it's a slap in the face to every veteran who has served pre-911 that their needs are not as important or egregious as our young heroes of today. There are vets out there today who served in non-combat situations, but still suffered devastating effects from hostile engagement that is not recognized by the VA. My brother is one of them.

It's abundantly clear that the men and women who serve on the front lines today are in serious jeopardy with their mental health...  but you are doing no favors to vets in general by categorizing them..  Vets from ALL combat eras are suffering..  We need to be inclusive. We demand better mental health services for ALL veterans.. and your article did nothing to address a solution..  It's a very strange way to end the article with "Your Turn." It doesn't fit, and you provide no closing for what people should do.

As a journalist/writer myself - it's a very sloppy piece..

DBSA
DBSA

@JerBear320

Thank you for sharing your thoughts.  You are correct, by some estimates Vietnam Veterans report experiencing recent PTSD symptoms 20-25 years after their tours.   We agree that PTSD is a mental health condition that requires access to quality care for all Veterans, regardless of theater.  The Expert Perspective from the Wounded Warrior Project is meant to share just one of the many treatment options available for certain groups, but is not intended to be read as the only option or that only Veterans serving in certain wars and conflicts experienced PTSD upon returning.